![]() ![]() You want to gain some insights from the way songs are used in the show, right? So let's not try to pigeonhole the show into different arbitrary categories, because it's like asking “But is Pluto really a planet or not?”. How similar is Generation Kill to My Fair Lady, Rocky Horror Picture Show, Chicago? If the last 3 are pigeon, flamingo, and sandgrouse, Generation Kill is more of a penguin. Words are used best, when they describe a dense similarity cluster, a group of things which look very-very similar to each other. It is true though, we should use words efficiently, not to confuse people. Words are just tools that we use to efficiently exchange information. Words don't have default, “correct” meanings, it's us, humans, who assign meaning to every word for convenience. Bollywood films feature songs and dancing, are they all musicals?Ĭlearly, arguments from dictionary are useless, because dictionaries are for documenting common usage of words, they do not prescribe how you should use the word. So it can or can't be a musical, depending on how many factors you require for it to qualify as a musical. Generation Kill uses songs as breaks in storyline, but not to advance plot. Wikipedia page on musical film describes it as “a film genre in which songs sung by the characters are interwoven into the narrative, sometimes accompanied by dancing” and also clarifies that “he songs usually advance the plot or develop the film's characters, though in some cases they serve merely as breaks in the storyline”. Generation Kill involves singing, so according to this dictionary definition it's a musical, sorta. ![]() Wiktionary describes musical as “a stage performance, show or film which involves singing, dancing and musical numbers performed by the cast as well as acting”. Depending on how you define the word “musical”, Generation Kill can either be a musical, or not. ![]() It's a very well-done start to a miniseries that feels as real as a documentary.Questions of the form “does x belong to category X?” are either meaningless or trivial, and the answer depends only on definition of X. Granted, there may have been overall plans but Wright's (who acts as a consulting producer for the series) account in this episode shows that the troops on the ground weren't aware of them. The episode is a solid hour, with little lag time and a definite message: these first Marines were sent in undersupplied and without any kind of actual plan of attack - or plan for dealing with surrendering Iraqis. His best scene this episode centers around his explanation for an accidental espresso fire to his superiors. Iceman appears to pull off being respected by both his fellow team members and his higher-ups. Ransone drives the Humvee of Team Leader Brad "Iceman" Colbert, played by Alexander Skarsgard, another stand-out character. Ransone has a number of amusing lines, including a long diatribe about the root cause of all world instability. Josh Ray Person, played by James Ransone, whom The Wire fans will recognize as season two's Chester "Ziggy" Sobotka. Several characters stand out from the crowd during " Get Some." Perhaps the most memorable is Cp. The cast is excellent, and populated with mostly unknown actors. Generation Kill begins with the First Recon Marines in Kuwait, awaiting orders at the Camp Mathilda staging ground for "Operation Iraqi Freedom." Before they roll out, they deal with boredom, supply shortages, a crazy wind storm, an espresso machine accident, and ridiculous grooming standards regarding exact specifications of moustaches and tucked-in shirts. It's a writing style well honed by writers David Simon and Ed Burns, the creators of the acclaimed HBO series The Wire. The writing is excellent, presenting a large number of characters, sometimes doing or saying something offensive, but displayed without judgment. This first episode thrusts us right into the action, meeting mouthy Marines and eventually Evan "Scribe" Wright, who accidentally impresses the troops when he mentions he used to write for Hustler. The miniseries, like the book, tells the story of the war from the perspective of the troops on the ground. Wright, understatedly played by frequent HBO actor Lee Tergesen ( Oz), was assigned to the First Reconnaissance Battalion - the first branch of the American military to march into Iraq. Generation Kill the miniseries follows the same nonfiction account of events as Wright's book, depicting real events, and using real names and actual dialogue from the Marines that Wright was embedded with in 2003.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |